Skip to main content

Every team is important too

 

Jeppe 3rd vs Benoni High 1st


One of the criticisms of professionally run school rugby programmes is that they absorb so much of the available funding in the school and channel it into the 1st team, and the other A teams, that there’s little over to fund the rest of the programme.

It happens in keeping with the ethos that winning games is the whole point of the exercise. Wins mean ranking points on the weekly published lists that are so popular with just about everyone except me – and no one cares what I think.

There are different ways of measuring success and, unfortunately, the performance of the 1st rugby team is regarded as one of the most significant. School rugby teams have come along in leaps and bounds. The top coaches employed by the elite schools have introduced cutting edge skills and tactical techniques, supported by science-based physical preparation, nutrition, sports psychology etc. All of that costs money and it has undoubtedly resulted in standards of play that are unrecognisably better than they were in the old teacher-coach “amateur” days.

Undoubtedly there are some schools who spend their money on all of the above and neglect the other rugby teams, and other sporting codes, but certainly not all. I’ve been a school sports reporter for over 30 years and in my experience the good schools are good at everything they do. And, as with everything, it comes down to leadership.

It’s the principal’s job to insist that the elite teams in the school are coached and prepared to a standard that allows them to be competitive against the best of their opponents (not to insist that they must win). But it’s also his/her job to create an environment that is ethical, educational and allows for the growth and development of all the pupils in the school.

There are school leaders, I’m afraid, who aren’t doing their job. They allow all sorts of things to go in which aren’t ethical and educational and then they try to excuse their actions by pointing out that the funding of their programmes come from somewhere else – from old boys, trust funds, wealthy benefactors, etc – the answer to that is that whatever goes on in the name of the school is their responsibility.

Thankfully, there are many who do their best to fulfil their mandate, often with great success. Because I’m so tired of whingeing about these things I want to look at some examples of those that I’ve come across in the past few weeks.

They show, in these particular instances, that there are elite rugby schools who go to a lot of effort to ensure that every rugby player, down to those in the lowest age group teams are coached, and that they play competitive games, every week.

When those sorts of schools play each other, and they will typically field 20 or more teams on a Saturday, everyone gets a game against the same opponents. This past weekend Grey College played Affies with 21 rugby teams, and Jeppe sent 20 teams by bus to Northwood in Durban. All 21 Grey teams played against Affies. But Northwood could only field 16 sides, so the other four Jeppe sides played teams from Pinetown Boy’s High – Es against As; 5ths and 6ths against 1st and 2nd – at some effort and expense because those boys weren’t hosted by Northwood so Jeppe had to find them a place to stay on Friday night.

On the same day, KES played St John’s, who can only field 14 teams these days. Fortunately, however, Pretoria Boys’ High were up against St Alban’s, who can’t match them for numbers, so they sent three teams to Houghton, and hosted two KES teams as part of their St Alban’s matchday  programme.

Benoni High School, who find themselves in a bit of a rugby desert on the East Rand, are admirably willing to fill in gaps – they played six games against KES as part of the KES vs Parktown fixture, and seven Benoni teams were part of a joint St David’s/Benoni fixture with Jeppe.

Get my point? In all of the above, the first teams and A age group teams were well catered for. If that was all that mattered, the easy thing would have been to give the others the weekend off and have an early Saturday. Instead, the schools willingly plunged into a logistical nightmare, and made money available for extra transport costs and paid student coaches and referees fees, just so that all their boys could get a game.

If as a school you are going to allocate five or six coaching personnel to your first rugby team, build and maintain a  gymn, feed them special meals, bring in consultants and - dare I say it -  cast out a money-gobbling recruitment net,  you'd better be sure that you look after the Es, Fs, 5th and 6ths too.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Queen's unexpected win was the highlight of a great school rugby week

  My sporting highlight of the week? …. It’s been rugby all the way and I got excited for various reasons, on Thursday already, about the Muir College vs Parktown game at Grey High, knowing that it was likely to be eclipsed as the long weekend unfolded. Then, on Friday night the Lions beat the Pumas in the Currie Cup. It’s always a highlight for me when they win these days, and that they stopped the defending champions made it more special. But the real stars this week were aways going to be the schoolboys and weren’t there some cracking games? Hilton holding out against nearly 10 minutes of ferocious attack from Michaelhouse to win 20-17 and extend their unbeaten run in the Midlands derby; and Jeppe scoring two tries in the final minute to snatch a draw against Selborne when the game looked gone for them, were two of them. At the Wildekalwer Festival in Kimberley where the big guns were playing, things went pretty much as expected, with no upsets. The Grey College vs Garsfon...
Post a Comment
Read more

It's rugby trials time, and I don't miss the cold

  My school sporting highlight of the week? It’s more a time of year, rather than an event, and I love it because of the memories it stirs: provincial rugby selection season. When the first chills of winter begin to bite, as they have this week, you know the Craven Week trials are on. I spent 10 years on those selection panels and the one consistent memory of those times is that it was bloody cold. On a typical U18 trials day the final game will kick off at around 5.30pm – sunset – and you’d have been on the side of the field in places like Alberton, or Krugersdorp, or, worst of all at UJ, deep in the valley and next to the Westdene Dam, all afternoon, steadily cooling down. We’d whinge, but I used to look forward to it all year, and from year to year.   It wasn’t easy. Trials are definitely not the best way to pick a team and, as the years passed, the task was made more difficult because racial quotas had to be met – it’s much worse now. And you’ll never please everyone...
Post a Comment
Read more

Meeting old friends has been the highlight of the weekend

  My school sports highlight of the weekend? …. The rugby festivals, obviously.   Everything about them, really, but in particular, for me, seeing some familiar faces, men and women who have spent much of their lives in service of sport at schools. There are too many to list them all, but I know there will be no offence taken if I’ve left someone out. I spoke of the guys in the KES Festival office the other day, Derron van Eeden, Neil Darroch and Ian Sim – people with weighty jobs over the festival weekend – but always gracious and courteous in all their dealings with everyone. And while I was at KES I saw Tinus Diedericks, the Golden Lions Schools Rugby chairman, Brad Ireland and Ian Rickelton, long-termers at St David’s, Hans Coetzee – a rugby coaching legend in these parts, and from the school cricket world, Niels Momberg, who is commentating on SuperSport Schools. Down the road at St John’s, I had a word with Arnold Geerdts, who has been the announcer there for the last 15...
Post a Comment
Read more